Was Xbox all digital a bad idea?

I like it. The only pitfall i see is you can't trade or sell your used games.

to me its very convenient for a lot of people, I don't mind running out to get a disc like the past days.

I think it was a good idea. Every Xbox one title is available digitaly in the Store.

Its been so long since i last used a Disc on my console, but i think they need to increase the hard drive space, and maybe the read/write speed too then,

To me it was. I have many disc games still.

I still wanna play them and not buy them over again.