The Severity of The Offense vs. The Severity of The Punishment

Discus and support The Severity of The Offense vs. The Severity of The Punishment in XBoX on Consoles to solve the problem; So recently, I sent two messages to an individual I know in real life and got a Communication ban for it. There's two things I want to express here:... Discussion in 'XBoX on Consoles' started by Cyvom, Oct 19, 2017.

  1. Cyvom
    Cyvom Guest

    The Severity of The Offense vs. The Severity of The Punishment


    So recently, I sent two messages to an individual I know in real life and got a Communication ban for it.

    There's two things I want to express here:

    1. I said one objectionable word.

    2. I got a week long ban from *every* social/messaging feature because of it for a whole week.

    I've had my account for six years, and never once had any sort of infraction against it. Now all of a sudden, because of *one* word, you can nearly have your account bricked? Where's the moderate in the moderation here?

    I understand that there's ToS, and that there are rules, but how far can you honestly take a first offense? I can't look for any posts on LFG, can't send messages, can't hear or speak in party chat, can't record with my DVR, can't use Skype, and can't broadcast
    on Mixer (and I even think I'm missing a couple of other things here.) Granted, I don't use all of these (Skype, at least on XBL, or Mixer,) but the principle of it is what I find ridiculous. Furthermore, it's only one week, and I'm busy at college, but
    still! Because you send one message with one word on a first-time offense, MS can ban you from all this social stuff for a disproportionately long amount of time?

    This is troubling. It shows how poor the moderation really is, how there's no real 'moderate' to it. No real common sense or gauge used to measure up the severity of the action with the severity of the deserved punishment.

    I even applied for a case review; I just got a copy paste message and a notice that the ban was upheld.

    The reputation system means nothing; it's just all about how bad of a day the 'moderator' was having at the time.

    I know you can't/won't help me out with this, but I'm honestly curious now: How does XBL Moderation judge what offense deserves what punishment?

    :)
     
    Cyvom, Oct 19, 2017
    #1
  2. x24hrs2livex
    x24hrs2livex Guest
    changed my dns but didnt know what it did

    The severity of the ban is up to the enforcement team. I am not apart of the enforcement tean so I cannot comment on the severity of your punishment. Also Rockstar may ban you.
     
    x24hrs2livex, Oct 19, 2017
    #2
  3. fixed

    It doesn't matter the severity of the offense, modifying your profile in ANY way breaks the terms of service and will result in a ban.
     
    xcrimsonlegendx, Oct 19, 2017
    #3
  4. An Old Freak
    An Old Freak Guest

    The Severity of The Offense vs. The Severity of The Punishment

    Xbox does not advise you of who made the report or when it was made.

    You are not given specifics partly to ensure the privacy and safety of the person making the report.

    Investigations take time. Each report is investigated before an enforcement action is taken.

    The Code of Conduct is in effect for parties just the same.

    All communications have to follow the Code of Conduct and be rated "E" for everyone.

    Your friends can report you, or something could have been found while another report was being investigated.
     
    An Old Freak, Oct 19, 2017
    #4
  5. Daft Badger
    Daft Badger Guest
    You can get a permanent ban for a first offence is it is severe enough.

    The rep system has nothing to do with whether you can get suspended or not,it's a separate thing.

    One word is enough to get a comms suspension & a communications suspension does just that,prevents you from communicating completely with anyone over xbox live.

    No one here can tell you the exact criteria the enforcement team use to judge how severe an offence it is & what punishment should be issued but the simple answer is don't violate the ToU/CoC & being suspended is something you wont have to worry about.
     
    Daft Badger, Nov 1, 2018
    #5
  6. Daft Badger Win User

    The Severity of The Offense vs. The Severity of The Punishment

    You can get a permanent ban for a first offence is it is severe enough.

    The rep system has nothing to do with whether you can get suspended or not,it's a separate thing.

    One word is enough to get a comms suspension & a communications suspension does just that,prevents you from communicating completely with anyone over xbox live.

    No one here can tell you the exact criteria the enforcement team use to judge how severe an offence it is & what punishment should be issued but the simple answer is don't violate the ToU/CoC & being suspended is something you wont have to worry about.
  7. An Old Freak Win User

    The Severity of The Offense vs. The Severity of The Punishment

    Xbox does not advise you of who made the report or when it was made.

    You are not given specifics partly to ensure the privacy and safety of the person making the report.

    Investigations take time. Each report is investigated before an enforcement action is taken.

    The Code of Conduct is in effect for parties just the same.

    All communications have to follow the Code of Conduct and be rated "E" for everyone.

    Your friends can report you, or something could have been found while another report was being investigated.
  8. DAVIIKUS Win User

    Suspended from Xbox?

    Hello, if you have insulted someone or committed an offense, a punishment has been applied to you, apparently it is not very severe, but if you repeat the punishments they will increase, a greeting.
  9. Gutter Yuppie Win User

    Communication Suspended

    Offensive gammertags would get a forced name change. Although I bet he'd get one if you reported it. Give it a try.

    Sounds like the OP sent several offensive messages. Each message is a separate offense and each offense increases the punishment.

    I don't believe support has access to enforcement history.
  10. NeoDan123 Win User

    How many suspensions until a ban?

    Good day

    The severity of the offence will determine the level of punishment and for how long.
Thema:

The Severity of The Offense vs. The Severity of The Punishment

Loading...
  1. The Severity of The Offense vs. The Severity of The Punishment - Similar Threads - Severity Offense Severity

  2. Xbox Cloud Gaming goes into a weird pixelated green screen for several seconds every 30ish...

    in XBoX Games and Apps
    Xbox Cloud Gaming goes into a weird pixelated green screen for several seconds every 30ish...: I have used xbox cloud gaming before on my older laptop or my steam deck with no issues. I just recently got a new heavier duty laptop and have been really excited to play my xbox games on the go,...
  3. On several games I own, I get the error 0xc000007b.

    in XBoX on Consoles
    On several games I own, I get the error 0xc000007b.: I've tried many things like like installing the C++ visual files and .net files. On one of the games I own I was able to see that in dependency walker one of the DLL files was a x86 file instead...
  4. A guy unlocked several achievements for me with a mod in a public game of black ops 2 at...

    in XBoX Games and Apps
    A guy unlocked several achievements for me with a mod in a public game of black ops 2 at...: I wonder if that can harm me my account is totally legal and I play current games and pay gamepass 92a973cc-d658-41dd-b8f2-2944cc378c41
  5. I updated my verification methods several times and it still don’t send verification codes...

    in XBoX Accessibility
    I updated my verification methods several times and it still don’t send verification codes...: How do I sign into my Xbox live account withought a verification code 318af35c-4a93-450c-9c5e-d7daedb0dfc9
  6. Severe xbox series controller drift

    in XBoX on Consoles
    Severe xbox series controller drift: Hello I dont want to be the kind of person to just complain about stuff but this is bs I purchased a xbox daystrike camo controller about 5 months ago and it has drift so bad its unusable my...
  7. How do I share games and in game content across several consoles in my house?

    in XBoX Games and Apps
    How do I share games and in game content across several consoles in my house?: I have an xbox series s and an xbox one. My wife and I have recently started playing online games together and I don’t know if I need to pay for everything twice? I am currently paying for two...
  8. How do I fix several inputs being registered after only 1 button press when streaming Xbox...

    in XBoX Games and Apps
    How do I fix several inputs being registered after only 1 button press when streaming Xbox...: When streaming from my console to my laptop, which is my only way to use my Xbox, for some games, notably Cyberpunk 2077 and Fortnite, after playing both once for 1 session, the next time I boot...
  9. Why can't anyone help but several people have the same issues???

    in XBoX Accessibility
    Why can't anyone help but several people have the same issues???: So I see that several people have had the same issues with several different games but just on their own profile is the only one having the issue well I'm having the same issue with rocket league...
  10. Windows 10 Microphone Quality Severely Degraded in Discord when in Game

    in XBoX Games and Apps
    Windows 10 Microphone Quality Severely Degraded in Discord when in Game: I have seen a couple other threads that are experiencing similar issues with no resolution. Within the past couple of weeks, I started having an issue where when I am in certain games (WZ2, Red...