if i get a Xbox one rechargeable battery and put it in Xbox one s will it work?

Hi I'm Luis a Xbox user just like you. Thanks for reaching out us here. Yes it should work since they all use a normal USB 2.0 or 3.0 input. You just need to have in mind that the new gen Xbox controller layout and input is different from the Xbox one. The new gen uses a C usb cable

will these work on xbox one s? Buy Xbox Rechargeable Battery + USB-C Cable - Microsoft Store

It's really worth it to get rechargeable batteries or a rechargeable Xbox One pack from Insignia like I have... It works great !!!

That's really strange they would both die together. Do you share the same rechargeable battery in them both? I wonder if it might be a issue with the rechargeable battery dying. I would try to put some regular AA batteries in them just to test and see
if they work, to rule out a issue with the rechargeable ones. Good luck!

To resolve this issue, determine the faulty component and then replace that component:

The Xbox One Wireless Controller

To troubleshoot the wireless controller, try using AA batteries, or try a different Xbox One Rechargeable Battery Pack to verify that nothing is wrong with the controller. If the controller works with different batteries, it isn't causing the issue.

The Xbox One Play & Charge cable

To check whether the cable is the problem, try a different Play & Charge cable (or any standard USB to micro-USB cable) to charge the battery. If the battery charges correctly with a different cable, your charge cable is faulty.

The rechargeable battery

To troubleshoot the rechargeable battery, try the following:

Use a cotton swab and some isopropyl alcohol to clean the four gold contacts on the Xbox One Rechargeable Battery Pack and on the Xbox One Wireless Controller. Then try to charge the battery again.

Try a different Xbox One Rechargeable Battery Pack with the charge cable. If the second battery charges correctly, your original battery is faulty.