I would like to know if i can fix my permanent communication ban??

All you can do is go to the enforcement site
here & file for a case review if eligible.

That's the only way to appeal a ban/suspension.If the decision gets upheld then that's it,the account will remain banned.

when i click on case review it wont let me file one..?

All you can do is go to the enforcement site
here & file for a case review if eligible.

That's the only way to appeal a ban/suspension.If the decision gets upheld then that's it,the account will remain banned.

Umm why in heavens name would you get any notifications on enforcement actions taken against accounts that isn't yours ?

You do realize that violates privacy laws right?

Regardless of you or him.filing a report on each other you neither are told of any action taken against them as its between them and the pet team

And fyi it doesn't matter who starts the fight you are accountable for YOUR own actions which result.in your suspension and his if he received one and no they won't tell you any result as that's between them and the other party.

Live life and play fair it's that simple

Also you can file a case review at https://enforcement.xbox.com if applicable but you already admitted to violating the terms of use

Fyi you aren't really allowed to retaliate hence why you are never given who reported you and why just the type of suspension.

Block ignore and report that's all you are allowed to do

The enforcement team don't use the forums.

All you can do is file for a case review here
http://enforcement.xbox.com/Home/HowTo#sub-topic0-6

Due to privacy you wont get the specifics

The enforcement team does send a thank you message occasionally. It's very rare.