360 "3d analog module" same as XOne module?

I fixed my controller for at least another 6 months by replacing the 3D Controller Joystick Axis Analog Sensor Module, which only cost $2.15 for the part. It was actually an easy fix if you know how to solder (soldering is very easy), but it still gets annoying
having to do it. So, does anyone know if you can use a xbox 360 3D Controller Joystick Axis Analog Sensor Module on an xbox one controller? The part looks and measures the same, but I don't know if it will act the same. Anybody have a clue, I know it was built
with a metal bracket opposed to plastic, so I'm wondering if that is why it doesn't break down as much as the xbox one. Please so input would be very appreciated!

There's a fix to this but you have to solder a new analog module on the controller. It isn't that hard and you save money.

Hey, I've had an elite controller pretty much since it came out. The only issue i hahad with it was the analog stick module malfunctioning after constant use

@CrypticBoz - the issue of the failing analog sticks has been of public knowledge for nearly two years and they've not addressed it, in fact the Elite controllers which are being sold on the pitch that they are of superior durability and craftsmanship as
to extend its longevity when on the contrary they are actually of the same shoddy build as the original controllers as they sport the same plastic pieces on the analog module that fail as with the original controllers, this is what causes the analog sticks
to fail and to develop stick drift

There is an officially licensed thrust master controller that has user replaceable sticks.

Unfortunately you’ve just gotten lucky, all three major manufacturers have used analog stick mechanisms from the same manufacturer for well over a decade. I had exactly the same problems with my 360

https://www.thrustmaster.com/en-us/products/eswap-x-s5-nxg-mini-stick-module/