Xbox live ban stepping on 5th amendment rights?

Discus and support Xbox live ban stepping on 5th amendment rights? in XBoX Games and Apps to solve the problem; SO I just got ban a 2nd time for having fun text brawls with other users in Battlefield. Particularly ones who are screwing around in the game ruining... Discussion in 'XBoX Games and Apps' started by MikeGallacher, Dec 30, 2016.

  1. Xbox live ban stepping on 5th amendment rights?


    SO I just got ban a 2nd time for having fun text brawls with other users in Battlefield. Particularly ones who are screwing around in the game ruining the experience for other players so I call them on it. Next thing you know the mindless xbox live enforcement
    trolls give me a 10 day suspension. I cant help but feel like this violates peoples rights to free speech especially when the ability to chat online was paid for. I'm really interested in seeing what routes to a class action law suit could be pursued against
    Microsoft and xbox live for overstepping their self proclaimed authority overriding constitutional rights.

    :)
     
    MikeGallacher, Dec 30, 2016
    #1
  2. davemcfly85
    davemcfly85 Guest
    Since I can't talk about this anywhere else...

    yeah there is no 1st amendment on xbox live or in the forums as MS is a private company not a government.
     
    davemcfly85, Dec 30, 2016
    #2
  3. Freedom of speech?

    Am I the only one that thinks the Xbox Live COC and Enforcement is a clear violation of the First Amendment?
     
    Manbearpig406, Dec 30, 2016
    #3
  4. Smwutches
    Smwutches Guest

    Xbox live ban stepping on 5th amendment rights?

    Freedom of speech does not apply to private businesses. When you sign up for Live, you agree to their terms of service and code of conduct which basically states that if you violate any of their terms, they have to right to suspend or cancel your service.
     
    Smwutches, Dec 31, 2016
    #4
  5. Free speech is the 1rst amendment. The 5th addresses incriminating yourself. The ROC addresses interaction with others, so don't get cranked about a law suit. It gets my goat when these players don't PTFO myself, but Microsoft won't condone you telling them
    what morons they are.
     
    GODofH3LLfire 2, Jan 20, 2017
    #5
  6. I feel for you i got banned by enforcement for having a conversation about a mini map in a game because thats 100% fair.
     
    UnoriginalScrub, Jan 21, 2017
    #6
  7. Any questions you have about any suspensions you're going through should probably be addressed to Enforcement.xbox.com and not the Battlefield 1 game forum, at the enforcement website you can see why the ban was put down and any options you have for repealing
    it.
     
    CyDieselDefendr, Nov 2, 2018
    #7
  8. CyDieselDefendr Win User

    Xbox live ban stepping on 5th amendment rights?

    Any questions you have about any suspensions you're going through should probably be addressed to Enforcement.xbox.com and not the Battlefield 1 game forum, at the enforcement website you can see why the ban was put down and any options you have for repealing
    it.
  9. UnoriginalScrub Win User

    Xbox live ban stepping on 5th amendment rights?

    I feel for you i got banned by enforcement for having a conversation about a mini map in a game because thats 100% fair.
  10. Smwutches Win User

    Xbox live ban stepping on 5th amendment rights?

    Freedom of speech does not apply to private businesses. When you sign up for Live, you agree to their terms of service and code of conduct which basically states that if you violate any of their terms, they have to right to suspend or cancel your service.
  11. GODofH3LLfire 2 Win User

    Xbox live ban stepping on 5th amendment rights?

    Free speech is the 1rst amendment. The 5th addresses incriminating yourself. The ROC addresses interaction with others, so don't get cranked about a law suit. It gets my goat when these players don't PTFO myself, but Microsoft won't condone you telling them
    what morons they are.
  12. steeledwand7664 Win User

    False ban

    "Sooner or later sobody will take xbox to court for violating the first amendment."

    I'm guessing it won't be you.

    You got banned for something else you did prior, that was reported, investigated and a ban issued to you. You got banned for 2 weeks because...………...wait for it...…..you have been banned before.
    As TurkeyGolf1 So eloquently copied and pasted one of my responses and said ( im not mad about it because its true)

    What a lot of people do not realize is that the bill of rights (first ten amendments) was put in place to protect the people from the government. lets look at each one

    1st amendment has already been talked about that CONGRESS shall pass no law abridging peoples rights.

    2nd amendment has been can be debated by many different ways.

    3rd restricts the federal government from going to a private citizen and telling them they have to allow a soldier to live in their house.

    4th basically says the government has to have a search warrant before they can enter your house

    5th Have you ever heard the saying I plead the 5th this is where it comes from it gives the person the right to not incriminate themselves in a court of law.

    6th basically says that you have a right to a fair and speedy trial, jury trial, right to confront any witnesses against you, right to know what charges are being brought against you. for criminal charges

    7th gurantees the same rights as 6 but for civil trials

    8th right against the government imposing excessive fines and cruel and unusual punishment.

    9th Says there is more rights the people have other then what is in the constitution.

    10th basically says if it isnt set forth for the federal government to do something in the constitution then it is up to the states.

    Do you see a pattern here the bill of rights was put in place to protect the people from the government whether it be the state level or the federal level it says nothing about a private company server that makes their own rules that you agreed to abide
    by when you signed up for the service.
Thema:

Xbox live ban stepping on 5th amendment rights?

Loading...
  1. Xbox live ban stepping on 5th amendment rights? - Similar Threads - live ban stepping

  2. Xbox Live Account Banned with Zero Strikes

    in XBoX on Consoles
    Xbox Live Account Banned with Zero Strikes: Hello, My Xbox Live account was banned with 0 strikes on the enforcements tab. I have been playing on xbox cloud gaming exclusively. I believe that there is some mistake. Is there anyway for me...
  3. Account that I don't use banned from Xbox Live

    in XBoX Accessibility
    Account that I don't use banned from Xbox Live: I know people are probably thinking, 'You don't get banned for no reason, you must have done something,' but I can explain. A few days ago, I received an email saying, 'The Xbox Safety team has...
  4. Hi, i was banned on xbox on the second week of living at university

    in XBoX Rewards & Social
    Hi, i was banned on xbox on the second week of living at university: Hi, i was banned on xbox on the second week of living at university with no explanation on why its come to the end of my university year and i would like to see at least why i was banned and if...
  5. If I purchase a console banned from Xbox live off Facebook would I be able to have it...

    in XBoX Games and Apps
    If I purchase a console banned from Xbox live off Facebook would I be able to have it...: Looking to buy a series s for use when I travel and saw a cheap one on Facebook that said it was banned from Xbox live. So my question is would I be able to get it unbanned so that I could use it...
  6. Banned from XBOX Live

    in XBoX Accessibility
    Banned from XBOX Live: I created this account 2 hours ago and i cant log on onto the XBOX windows 10 app because it says my account has been suspended from xbox live. I can log in, from my phone, browser, my friend...
  7. My son uses my live account, its now banned for 2 months because he put up a gamer pic that...

    in XBoX Accessibility
    My son uses my live account, its now banned for 2 months because he put up a gamer pic that...: I've been a live customer since the very beginning, when xbox first came out. I have NEVER had a complaint against me and I am absolutely disgusted with how I have been treated. My 13 year old...
  8. i was banned for literally no reason from xbox live is there no one i can contact about...

    in XBoX Accessibility
    i was banned for literally no reason from xbox live is there no one i can contact about...: Xbox banned me for no reason and i sent an appeal only to be instantly denied, ive tried to find ways to contact and i just dont know how to, i really dont want to lose an account ive had for as...
  9. Banned from Xbox live today for no reason nor was I given one

    in XBoX Accessibility
    Banned from Xbox live today for no reason nor was I given one: Today I was told that my Xbox live account is suspended indefinitely for violating community standards. I appealed and it was denied with, again, no explanation as to why! This isn’t fair as I’m...
  10. How come I get banned from Xbox live for bad language and my thread gets locked

    in XBoX Games and Apps
    How come I get banned from Xbox live for bad language and my thread gets locked: While playing cod zombies I went down and I asked for help and a player got mouthy with me calling me a **** a retard and everything under the sun and I get banned from live when there’s strong...