Xbox 360 Slim disc tray is not working at all? How can i fix it?

If I had to guess, I would say both of your 360's need to be fixed. I have had disc tray problems with 3 separate xbox 360's, each one was a disc tray issue similar to what you describe. Some games took a long time to work, others didn't want to work at
all, sometimes I would have to open and close my disc tray dozens of times to get a game to work.

The reason it doesn't work is because something is broken inside of your disc tray, or something that deals with your disc tray functionality.

Like I said, this is just a guess.

I did try it with no game in the disc tray, yes. I took it out on day 1 when this all started.

I just borrowed another Xbox 360 Slim -- Same Model # (1439) and manufactured in the same month as mine, and it works with no issues on my monitor, so this 100% proves it is my Xbox 360 Slim that is the cause of the problem. I give up.

What type of Xbox 360 is it? Slim? Has there been any physical damage to the disc tray?

I got a brand new xbox 360 slim in christmas 2011. A month later, the power button blinks/flashes. And the disk tray open and closes. On the xbox home menu, it says the *** is opening( even when the tray is fully open) or close tray. Can someone PLEASE help
me. Xbox boxes break so easy. I thought the slim would be better. but it only lasted a month. I probably going to get ps4 instead of xbox720 if microsoft don't fix all the problems with xboxes.

Hey there Fife,

Sorry to hear you're having issues with your disc tray.

I would be careful with your disc tray, we really don't recommend you force it as that may further damage the console.

What style of Xbox 360 console do you have? (original white, xbox slim, etc.)

Let us know and we'll work with you from there.