Why did they make the analog sticks on the Xbox One controller so loose?

I know people are complaining about the controller, for me it the best yet without a doubt. I use very high sensitivity, so with the added subtle control this controller gives me for FPS is welcomed and amazing - takes awhile to catch on. Trigger force
feedback on Forza really does work fantastically (I don't use assists), I love actually feeling the tires.

 

I didn't realise how much I liked the new controller until I went back to the 360, now going back and using the old controller is the worst part of the 360.

 

@Goth Vampirella Ha ha there aren't many of them as it only auto records when i level up lol

 

It took me a few days before I got totally used to the new controller. At one point I was playing Extinction with my friends and a friend said he just loves the new controller and I laughed because it was so comfortable I forgot I was using it. Almost everything
is great on it, the dpad & face buttons have a great clicking feel to it, the triggers are so smooth, the sticks are fine. The only small thing for me was the bumper buttons being a bit too high, but nothing unbearable.

 

I prefer the X360 Controller over the New one. I just don't like the feel. If it aint broken, Don't fix it!!!!!!!

 

I actually like the way they've made the analogue sticks. The L-R-up-down arrow buttons sound tinny when you press them though, compared to the 360's controller. The controller is light and fits in my hands more better which I like, and to me the trigger
buttons make less noise than the 360's controller.

 

The triggers do make a lot less noise, I love it. Also the light weight of it is nice.

I wasn't that fond of it during the first week but now it feels a lot better than 360.

 

When i first saw my controller i was like WTF?? what happen to the thumb sticks?? lol but after playing a few times with it when i first got it all was good!...The X1 controller is head and shoulders above the 360 one IMO.

 

Didn't know this. Another reason why I'm glad I didn't rush my decision to buy one.

 

I must be the only one then that instantly felt comfortable with the new controller, for me it's such a massive improvement and going back to the old 360 controller feels weird for me now.

 

I liked more resistance for shooters, found i had more control and could be more precise, getting used to them now but wish the diameter was a little wider on the joysticks

 

The 360 controller is hands down better feeling and much more responsive. The bumpers and triggers on the 360 hands down are better than the ONE. Change is good and I will adjust to the ONE one day, but for now I use my kontrol freeks for all my games on
the one.

 

I bet they have modded controllers you can buy with all sorts of colors already. Just a thought. And btw I swear microsoft makes the controllers smaller with each game console.. id love to compare the original with the new one.

 

Tbh, think I got used to them on day one. I have adapted.

 

Well my 360 controller is the one that came with my first console. Its had a lot of use sp the analog sticks have kind of lost their resistance so when I started using the controller I personally didn't really that kind of difference in the analog sticks.