Why can I not sync 2 identical controllers to my 360?

Discus and support Why can I not sync 2 identical controllers to my 360? in XBoX on Consoles to solve the problem; I bought 2 new controllers for my 360, they are identical. I can sync them to my console one at a time but can not synce them both. One will sync and... Discussion in 'XBoX on Consoles' started by lacey D, Feb 9, 2024.

I bought 2 new controllers for my 360, they are identical. I can sync them to my console one at a time but can not synce them both. One will sync and the other continues to search. I shut the controller off that synced and the other will finally sync in. But then the other won't again!. Can I not have two of the same controller synced at the same time? I have multiple others that sync in just fine. These two are the only ones that are the same.

:)