Tomb Raider, Assassins Creed Black flag or Murdered Soul Aspect?

I am thinking about getting one of these games for the Xbox One but cant decide what one to get first. So if you were in my shoes which one would you choose?

:)

 

Want game with a good and long campaign

If you haven't played them, you might want to look into the recent Assassins Creed (including Black Flag) and Tomb Raider games also. They usually keep me busy for a good stretch and I have always enjoyed the stories.

 

Xbox One transfer cable from the 360 to the One ?

I thought Microsoft came out and said XBOX ONE is Backwards compatable now... I have a ton of downloaded games on my old XBOX 360 that id like to transfer to XB1. (Assassins Creed Black Flag, Thief, Tomb Raider, and much more...)

 

AC4, All good games but that one is longer I guess.

 

I'd go with Tomb Raider, especially if you haven't played it on the 360 yet. Looks great and didn't mind the story. Gameplay is also heaps of fun.

ACIV is huge with a lot to do, but really it's AC with boats, I wasn't too thrilled with the story myself either.

From what I've seen Murdered: Soul Suspect is one to wait on for a long time. I'll get it maybe around Christmas.

 

Having played all 3, here's my opinion. If you liked the other AC games then you'll love Black Flag. The naval combat is worth the price of admission alone. Like RedEye said, it's really long so you get your money's worth, and then some. Tomb Raider is my
favorite of the 3 but that's strictly subjective. I loved Tomb Raider. Great Story and gameplay. One of the best action/adventure games I've played in a long time. It's basically the Xbox's version of Uncharted so if you have a PS3 and liked that game then
you really can't go wrong. Murdered: Soul Suspect is a mixed bag. Kinda like a supernatural L.A Noire that can be beaten in a day, so you definitely DON'T get your money's worth. I'd rent it if I were you. I did and had a good time but I would've felt violated
had I paid full price.

 

Honestly, Tomb Raider and AC4 have been some of the best games I've played in a while and that was on the 360. If I were to get one to replay I'd get AC4 cause it's just such a massive, long and fun game. I wouldn't pass up on Tomb Raider doe. There's a
reason a definitive edition came to next gen. It was pretty amazing.

 

Thanks for the advice Red eye, Digi, Nappy and Defy much appreciated

I decided to get Assassins Creed black flag first. Just bought it for $47 dollars, the stores computer rung it up wrong and the dude behind the counter said I could have it for that price instead of the $57 price.

I will possibly get Tomb Raider next week.

I think ill wait it out a bit more with Murdered Soul Aspect.

 

Forget Murdered: Soul Suspect. You'll be done with it in about three days. It's really short, and doesn't have much substance. If you want to play it, then rent it, don't buy it.

 

Tomb Raider all the way! I'm sure graphics will be even more enhanced on xbox 1 compared to 360.

 

Tomb Raider. The problem with the new AC game is you either hate it or love it there isn't really much of an inbetween. Personally the ship combat is what ruined it for me because it just felt so clunky.

 

I'd say go for AC Black Flag, as I enjoyed the story much more. I haven't played Murdered Soul Suspect yet though. As for Tomb Raider, it has great gameplay, but the story is just bad imo. I think AC4 has more to do than Tomb Raider.

 

You won't beat "Murdered Soul Suspect" in a day unless you're sat in front of Youtube watching a "walkthrough".

Of the 3 games you mention "Murdered Soul" offers you something new and original but be aware that it's a slow paced game designed for those who love to explore and collect everything.

Once you've finished it there's little replay value but then you can pick it up for a very decent price so it's worth going for if you can pick it up for a decent price and you're actually gonna play it instead of aping a Youtube guide.

 

Murdered: Soul Suspect can be beaten in a day. I finished it in about 6 or 7 hours and I collected most of the collectables and did all the ghost' side stories.

I recommend both Assassin's Creed IV and Tomb Raider. Murdered: Soul Suspect is good, but it's a rental.

 

Yes I think ill be waiting till Murdered Soul Aspect gets cheaper. Id rent it but the dvd rental place where I live don't do next gen games. I suppose I could rent it on Xbox 360.