Terraria Sale Price

You would need to contact support and speak to billing, but there are no guarantees. 1-800-4my-xbox if you're in the US/Canada or
support.xbox.com/contact-us

The deal for the Gold special price for Terraria was from August 5-11 as per Major Nelson's blog post.

majornelson.com/.../weeks-deals-gold-4

If you attempted to purchase it today, which was a day late for the sale, you probably would have had the regular price anyway.

I would recommend keeping an eye on Major Nelson's blog in the future to stay up to date on current sales and offers.

nah the pricing is way off, the thing is, if you track sales you are paying more for GoD games than retail, and when you factor in trade in values it's worse. sometimes GoD games are priced ok, but they never seem to drop down in price, they should have
people actively downing prices for digital games, its why steam is so popular, they have some games that are $40 on xbox for $10, heck the day terraria came out on xbox for $15 it was $2 on steam, anyone who touches PC wouldn't buy the xbox version when they
could save $12 and get it on pc.

One of the prices listed is the sale price for silver members (not the original price), the other is the sale price for gold members. The original price is actually not listed in the store during a sale like this. So the prices are the correct percentages
off.

Actually it's listed at the right percentage, it's just listed differently than regular sales. During the ultimate sale, the games are on sale for everyone, but are on sale at a higher percentage for gold members. So where it normally lists the regular price,
that's the sale price for silver members and the price above is the sale price for gold members.