Reputation system bug?

So whats is going on with my rep?

Got a message from a friend this morning and said what happened to your reputation? So i checked it out and it's on Orange "Needs Work"

Then an hour or so later it went back to Green "Good" I thought this may have been because it was the 1st Sepember which may have reset? Not sure how that works

Ok so i got online battlefield 4 and just mucked around on test range for a bit,
No multiplayer. within 30mins it went back to "Needs Work"

how can this happen? just goes to show you how flawed the system is.

Screenshot today of the correct rep showing Good and green on the graph

[View:http://i.imgur.com/bgCl2Zgl.png?1:550:0]

Screenshot 1hr later to current- Orange "Needs work" and still Green in the graph, Same stats. Wrong reputation given.

[View:http://i.imgur.com/NP2Zp4Kl.png?1:550:0]

So remember it went from Needs Work>Good>Needs Work. all within a couple of hours graphs says it's still in the Green though. so whats right?

How i even have a bad rep is beyond me i'm an older gamer who keeps to myself. only really play online with one friend.

not to concerned at the moment but something is not right with this system and bannings aren't right

:)

 

About the reputation system..

Major Nelson recently did a feature on his site reference the reputation system that might be of interest.

majornelson.com/.../xbox-live-reputation-system-details

 

MS was advertising feedback system!??!!? Why bother?

According to this website blocking and muting does effect reputation.

www.computerandvideogames.com/.../xbox-one-reputation-system-will-filter-cheaters-and-griefers

 

It's called rep trolling...xbox has no idea how to fix it so the pump up a few forums trolls to say its fine and we must be baad players....bottom line is if you do good at a game be prepared to suffer....

 

^ agreed. Thx for the reply

So today my rep changed again. Makes alot of sense right?

[View:http://i.imgur.com/2Rgwg7P.png?1:550:0]

 

Crazy stuff man....lets just put it this way....if it was broke...they would never admit it...oh well...we pay they say...lol

 

Yeah 4th time Reputation has changed in 2 days. no stat differences. But it's working correctly apparently :S

 

What do you know it's on "Needs Works" again. changes are so random.

 

The sheer amount of posts should be indication enough that there's an issue...on to PS 4 lol