Platinum rule

Discus and support Platinum rule in XBoX Accessibility to solve the problem; Q: Are there problems with the platinum rule? A: Yes, Q: So what are the problems? Let’s use a rather repugnant and simple example that will... Discussion in 'XBoX Accessibility' started by L25 1R5, Aug 1, 2022.

  1. L25 1R5
    L25 1R5 Guest

    Platinum rule


    Q: Are there problems with the platinum rule?

    A: Yes,

    Q: So what are the problems?

    Let’s use a rather repugnant and simple example that will demonstrate some problems.

    Suppose a young gamer comes across an unknown pedophile gamer and the two strike up some conversation. It may happen the pedophile gamer asks the kid to send some indecent messages and photos through, or even wants to meet! This, after all, would be how the person would want to be treated. According to your platinum rule “Treat others as they’d like to be treated”, it follows that child would then feel obligated to treat this person as they want. By following your rule and treating this person as they want to be treated an evil beyond measure would have been brought about! The safety and well-being of the child is at serious risk. Purely sinister.

    Is it the case that xbox wishes to be a leading conduit of evil in society?

    * The platinum rule negates personal autonomy and gives strange people authority over one’s own conduct.

    * How another person wants to be treated may be illegal!

    *How another person wants to be treated may conflict with common decency and the common good.

    *How another person wants to be treated may conflict with a ones own values. Why should a person negate their own values for some unknown person with who knows what intention and dispositions?

    *The platinum rule exposes the weak and opens the door to all manner of evils.

    The above are just some of the many serious issues with xbox’s ethical efforts.

    :)
     
    L25 1R5, Aug 1, 2022
    #1
  2. JosefLBohorquez Win User

    Platinum rule

    As I said, is a complement

    You're not going to be racist with someone else if they ask you to do that.

    If that happens the other person is trolling you or want that Microsoft bans you to use the Xbox live network

    No one is going to risk their account access, as I said earlier in those kind of situations is when each individual should use their reasoning and analyze the situation and proceed

    You can take a look to the full community standards, examples like the ones that you give lead always to a banned account to the person who commit the action (<trolling> wants that someone else says racist things, and to the person who says the racists things):
    https://www.xbox.com/en-US/legal/community-stan...

    The Xbox network is always monitored to avoid those situations

    If you want you can try waiting until someone else reply to this thread. But probably they're going to say the same as I
  3. L25 1R5 Win User

    Platinum rule

    That’s extraordinary.

    You are stating that the rule that enables racist behaviour is a good thing.

    Wow!
  4. JosefLBohorquez Win User

    Platinum rule

    I don't see a flaw on it, sorry
    And if there is a flaw for children, as advised above

    In that part is where the parent needs to intervene restricting child's activity online, like in the internet in general
  5. JosefLBohorquez Win User

    Platinum rule

    If you ask me I don't quite get your point. I don't see nothing wrong with the rule

    If you think something's wrong with it please share this idea or how the rule needs to be rewritten with the Xbox team via Insiders subreddit:

    https://www.reddit.com/r/xboxinsiders/wiki/ideas
  6. JosefLBohorquez Win User

    Platinum rule

    Someone is going to report that behavior, the consequences is a ban to the people who are racist / discriminatory

    All that is stated here:

    https://support.xbox.com/en-US/help/friends-soc...

    In that way, the platinum rule is a complement for the general Xbox Live Network rules
Thema:

Platinum rule

Loading...

  1. Platinum rule - Similar Threads - Platinum rule

  2. Will Xbox ever add any thing equivalent to the PlayStation platinum trophy?

    in XBoX Games and Apps
    Will Xbox ever add any thing equivalent to the PlayStation platinum trophy?: I love achievement hunting and I love Xbox but I have no incentive to 100% games. If I’m playing a story game I usually play it on my PS5 instead. It’s a minor change but would make a massive...

  3. Bought 2000 platinum in Diablo IV through Xbox and cannot access it.

    in XBoX Games and Apps
    Bought 2000 platinum in Diablo IV through Xbox and cannot access it.: Hi I Bought 2000 platinum in Diablo IV through Xbox and cannot access it. I have the game on battle.net and also have bought game pass to access the platinum because I read it's required to open...

  4. I set up a new profile, bought game pass platinum and I can't join Xbox live! ****?!

    in XBoX Accessibility
    I set up a new profile, bought game pass platinum and I can't join Xbox live! ****?!: Why after purchasing game pass platinum and a new profile, join Xbox live? f1e9e5dc-ac71-4219-a781-861dcba8a41f

  5. Will there ever be a Platinum trophy equivalent?

    in XboX Insiders
    Will there ever be a Platinum trophy equivalent?: When I had recently started achievement hunting I realized there isn’t anything similar to a platinum trophy. submitted by /u/tygamble [link] [comments]

  6. make a platinum equivalent for xbox

    in XboX Insiders
    make a platinum equivalent for xbox: why doesn't Xbox have something similar because 100% the game doesn't feel as good it's just like any other rare achievement, it's unnecessary yeah but it's cool af. submitted by /u/Davidson890...

  7. The platinum rule is flawed.

    in XBoX Accessibility
    The platinum rule is flawed.: How does this work if one person wants to talk but another doesn't and the one who doesn't expects the platinum rule to be applied to them and not the other way around? What if it's determined by...

  8. Will Xbox ever add any thing equivalent to the PlayStation platinum trophy?

    in XBoX Games and Apps
    Will Xbox ever add any thing equivalent to the PlayStation platinum trophy?: I’ve been achievement hunting on another account but I’ve always wanted something to show that I have fully completed a game and I want Xbox to add something similar to the platinum, is it...

  9. Why can’t I purchase the fs22 dlc platinum expansion

    in XBoX Games and Apps
    Why can’t I purchase the fs22 dlc platinum expansion: Having problems buying the fs22 platinum expansion for Xbox 3612c12a-879d-4d41-b522-a9921ea61a3e

  10. Xbox Series X Crashing Playing GTA5 Platinum Edition

    in XBoX on Consoles
    Xbox Series X Crashing Playing GTA5 Platinum Edition: Hay. So here’s my issue. If I play GTA5 and turn the console off to go do other things. I come back to it and land on the Home Screen, I select GTA5 again I get the main splash screen but then it...