My friends and I can connect with my public IP, but I can't connect with my private IP

Discus and support My friends and I can connect with my public IP, but I can't connect with my private IP in XBoX Games and Apps to solve the problem; I seem to be having the opposite problem as most people I've seen on Google. I'm using a second PC to host my Minecraft server with a few mods (port... Discussion in 'XBoX Games and Apps' started by wreede peper, Jul 4, 2022.

  1. wreede peper
    wreede peper Guest

    My friends and I can connect with my public IP, but I can't connect with my private IP


    I seem to be having the opposite problem as most people I've seen on Google. I'm using a second PC to host my Minecraft server with a few mods (port forwarded and everything). Originally, I connected with my public IP from my main PC, but I found that after a few minutes, I would get kicked from the server, so I instead connected through the second PC's private IP, which solved the problem. The rest of my friends connect through my public IP and they can still play just fine. However, after two days, I could not join through the private IP anymore because it would get stuck on "Loading Terrain". The IP didn't change, nothing in my firewall changed. In fact, I let every instance of Java through my firewall just to be sure. Does anyone know what happened or what I can do? TIA.

    :)
     
    wreede peper, Jul 4, 2022
    #1
  2. Xx ROZILLA xX Win User

    moderate nat better than open nat?

    ok with open NAT and port forward I have many more connections than with moderate NAT.

    There is no connection public to public which are not my public Adresses - but there are connections

    Public IP to MY public IP and this even if I´m not Host.

    As Source IP there is an public IP who is not mine. With moderate NAT I see only my internal connect to external public adresses.
  3. Unbeatable95 Win User

    How can i open my NAT ?

    and how can i change my private IP to a public one ?

    can i call the company to change it or to add new things on my connection ?

    i've heard also about "APN", but the question is how can i change my ISP to a public ?
  4. Xx ROZILLA xX Win User

    moderate nat better than open nat?

    ok with the new Firmware I can check all connections on my Router.

    Normally on my Router is:

    IP: 192.168.1.xx on Port 3074 connected to public IP Adress on Port 3074

    with open Nat is see it also but I also see some things like that:

    public IP on port 65xxx connected to public IP on port 3074

    both are not my public IP´s. Does it mean that I host parts of the game even if I´m not the host?

    Is this, why moderate NAT is better for me?
  5. Tezzarrific Win User

    Xresolver

    All IP addresses are public information, they are not private in anyway.

    an IP address can be obtained easily even without this site, it is what you do with the IP address that can be illegal.

    When you connect to a party or a P2P game all IPs are broadcast, and this information is not private.
  6. Xx ROZILLA xX Win User

    moderate nat better than open nat?

    and now I see:

    public IP (not mine) source port 61254

    pubic IP (also not mine) source port 54720 connect both to my public IP.
Thema:

My friends and I can connect with my public IP, but I can't connect with my private IP

Loading...
  1. My friends and I can connect with my public IP, but I can't connect with my private IP - Similar Threads - friends connect public

  2. My Xbox series x won’t connect to my friends wifi but it works fine on my home network....

    in XBoX Games and Apps
    My Xbox series x won’t connect to my friends wifi but it works fine on my home network....: Already tried factory reset and that didn’t help. Also tried manually setting up ip address and that didn’t fix the issue either. c726113d-ac06-4930-a2a2-6b87d699b619
  3. When I go to play one certain game with friends it says can’t connect with them due to MTU...

    in XBoX on Consoles
    When I go to play one certain game with friends it says can’t connect with them due to MTU...: I have an MTU issue When I go to play one certain game with friends it says can’t connect with them due to MTU problem but I was just on the online multiplayer with some randoms earlier whys am I...
  4. How do I change my child’s permissions? They want to connect with their friends online to...

    in XBoX Accessibility
    How do I change my child’s permissions? They want to connect with their friends online to...: My kids want to play Mine Craft with their friends online. However their current permission settings in the family app prevent that. I can’t figure out how to change their permissions in the...
  5. Can't connect to friend's minecraft server

    in XBoX Games and Apps
    Can't connect to friend's minecraft server: Trying to connect to a friend's minecraft server however I am unable to. The server is modded and I am using curseforge launcher to play. Whenever I load onto the curseforge profile and try join...
  6. My Friend can't Connect to my Minecraft Realm

    in XBoX Games and Apps
    My Friend can't Connect to my Minecraft Realm: I've invited my friend to my Minecraft Realm, and every time he tries to connect, he is met with an error message that reads "internal exception java.net.socketexception connection reset". I've...
  7. Why can't my friends microsoft account connect to Minecraft PS5?

    in XBoX Accessibility
    Why can't my friends microsoft account connect to Minecraft PS5?: Hello, me and my friends would like to Minecraft together. But every time one of my friends tries to make a Microsoft account it doesn't work to connect with Minecraft. He has tried his dad's...
  8. My Xbox controller won’t connect to my Xbox series X after coming home from a friends house

    in XBoX on Windows
    My Xbox controller won’t connect to my Xbox series X after coming home from a friends house: My Xbox controller won’t connect to my Xbox series X after coming home from a friends house 1f51beb9-acd9-4b24-b420-a36079c751b5
  9. Xbox won't load games, friends, or anything else, but is connected to the internet.

    in XBoX on Consoles
    Xbox won't load games, friends, or anything else, but is connected to the internet.: Issue resolved. Thank you. 39a9c321-2f1f-451d-9680-fdac00ba79ee
  10. Why is my 360 showing what friends are active, but saying I can't connect to the internet?

    in XBoX on Consoles
    Why is my 360 showing what friends are active, but saying I can't connect to the internet?: My system says i'm not connecting to the internet, however it shows what friends are online. Tested the ethernet cable in a Sony console and it worked fine. How can it show what friends are online...