Moderate NAT - Both XBOX 360 & XBOX ONE Connected to Same Network...

ISP Provider: Verizon FIOS

Router: Actiontec MI424WR

Summary: Can't manage to get an "OPEN" NAT on both my XBOX ONE and my XBOX 360.

Description:

1) Both consoles are connected to the same Router and the same Verizon Fios network.

2) I've gone through the steps of opening the appropriate ports. HOWEVER, the router does not allow me to open Ports for both consoles as you can only have a port open for one specific IP Address.

3) Here's what I've tried. I tried PORT FORWARDING for one console and then had the second console's IP address on DMZ. Unfortunately, this doesn't seem to work.

4) Long story short, it appears that I can only manage to get one console with an "OPEN NAT" at a time. In order to make the other console have an Open Nat, I have to take 20 min to switch the router settings which is ridiculously impractical and doesn't
work 100% of the time.

I'm sure someone out there has both an XBOX ONE and an XBOX 360 connected to the same network and has both working properly (both with Open Nat). Can anyone provide me some insight on what I can do?

I'd REALLY appreciate it.

:)

 

Moderate NAT - Both XBOX ONE & XBOX 360 Connected to Same Network (HELP!)

As you noted, a port can only be forwarded to one IP. When you manually forward ports to Xbox A, those ports are no longer available to be forwarded to Xbox B. Placing Xbox B in the DMZ will not help because doing so essentially just forwards all available
ports to Xbox B, and the needed ports are no longer available because you forwarded them to Xbox A. The only way to get open NAT on both at the same time is to use UPnP on a good router that has a working UPnP implementation (many home routers don't). To
try it, enable UPnP on your routrr and remove all Xbox-related port forwards and DMZ.

 

Moderate NAT - Both XBOX ONE & XBOX 360 Connected to Same Network (HELP!)

It possable. But I think you need a better router. My care give moldem router combo is putty good leting to be connected good. So a better router would be firth thing to tried. Unless some network export come in this topic and says about making open nat
on both on the one you have now.