Is this a legitamte reason to report?

I never said the majority of things you have bought up,that was another ambassador.

I replied twice in your original thread telling you where to go to find out about the rep system & informing you that Blizzard are nothing to do with xbox live.

I then replied in your 2nd thread informing you that making duplicate threads is not allowed.

At no point was I rude or treated you unfairly.

Both threads were locked because you were given the correct answers.

That's not what I said.

I never said everyone who doesn't use chat should be reported.

What i said was if you do not communicate with your team in a team based game it can be considered unsportsman like behaviour.

Unsportsman like behaviour can lower your rep.

Playing a character that someone doesn't like isn't a legit reason to report someone.

Of course you enjoyed the input of the ambassador that posted first,it was the answer you wanted to hear.

As I already mentioned,it doesn't matter anyway,if a report is false then it will have no impact on your rep whatsoever.

I very rarely play team based games with randoms now because no one communicates.

Actually the majority of xbox users do use headsets,they are just usually in party chat.

Do you agree with the other ambassador in that thread that I should "obey" my team? And when he purposely made a personal insult at me by saying "arguementive yet you claim to be a good sportman (That telling of your behavior)"? Do you support that kind
of treatment towards the community? If not, why do you not calmly correct it?

That's not what I said.

I never said everyone who doesn't use chat should be reported.

What i said was if you do not communicate with your team in a team based game it can be considered unsportsman like behaviour.

Unsportsman like behaviour can lower your rep.

Playing a character that someone doesn't like isn't a legit reason to report someone.

Of course you enjoyed the input of the ambassador that posted first,it was the answer you wanted to hear.

As I already mentioned,it doesn't matter anyway,if a report is false then it will have no impact on your rep whatsoever.

I very rarely play team based games with randoms now because no one communicates.

Actually the majority of xbox users do use headsets,they are just usually in party chat.

" I never said everyone who doesn't use chat should be reported.

What i said was if you do not communicate with your team in a team based game it can be considered unsportsman like behavior."

But doesn't not being in chat mean you're not communicating? And therefore is unsportsman like and could earn you a valid report?

You said you rarely play with randoms because they rarely communicate, but did you report them all for not communicating? Do you think it would be valid to?

That's not what I said.

I never said everyone who doesn't use chat should be reported.

What i said was if you do not communicate with your team in a team based game it can be considered unsportsman like behaviour.

Unsportsman like behaviour can lower your rep.

Playing a character that someone doesn't like isn't a legit reason to report someone.

Of course you enjoyed the input of the ambassador that posted first,it was the answer you wanted to hear.

As I already mentioned,it doesn't matter anyway,if a report is false then it will have no impact on your rep whatsoever.

I very rarely play team based games with randoms now because no one communicates.

Actually the majority of xbox users do use headsets,they are just usually in party chat.

I never said the majority of things you have bought up,that was another ambassador.

I replied twice in your original thread telling you where to go to find out about the rep system & informing you that Blizzard are nothing to do with xbox live.

I then replied in your 2nd thread informing you that making duplicate threads is not allowed.

At no point was I rude or treated you unfairly.

Both threads were locked because you were given the correct answers.

Why can you guys not just admit that the reputation system is flawed and abused and sometimes people get reported and lose reputation when they have done nothing wrong?

This ambassador had no problem admitting it:

https://forums.xbox.com/en-US/thread/73B93911-D863-4B75-9018-6C0368D4521D

"The reputation system is indeed flawed, even Microsoft has admitted it -- allegedly they're working on it. There's always some good players that can get unfairly marked as "Avoid Me", and mistakes like that are always happening."