Is it possible to get a community guidelines ban for breaking the profile guidelines?

Sgt. Helios [Task Force: · Feb 17, 2025 at 2:42 AM

Basically just wondering if there are actually different types of guidelines that can be broken, (profile, community, ect) because a friend claims he got banned for his profile picture (a picture of a cars brakes glowing orange due to overuse) under the code of Community guidelines being broken but as far as i know that would go under Profile Guidelines, no?

:)

Daft Badger

Community guidelines is just the general name for all the rules on xbox live

[Farscape]

even if politics was allowed it can still then be treated as advertising which is against the rules. leave politics out of gaming please.

Daft Badger

As a rule of thumb,if you have to ask or have any doubts then don't do it.

Would you get into trouble? Possibly as it could be classed as a controversial topic.

Another thing to remember is that a lot of people play xbox & come on xbox live to get away from real life stuff & don't particularly want to see that sort of stuff on xbox live.

Etag_Mixer

Did your post contain banned language? or was it abusive?

Usually this sort of thing happens if your post breaks the forum guidelines, which are there to keep the conversations as positive and constructive as possible

David Wirsching

Hello Correy C, My name is David. I am an independent advisor, happy to help you today.

I can provide some general information that may help you understand why this situation occurred.

Many online platforms, including gaming consoles like Xbox, use automated systems to monitor and enforce community guidelines. These systems employ algorithms and AI to detect potential violations. While they can catch some violations, they are not perfect and can sometimes make mistakes or have false positives.

In some cases, content is initially approved by automated systems but later flagged by manual review. It's possible that a human moderator reviewed your profile picture after it was accepted and determined that it violated community guidelines, leading to your ban.

Community guidelines can change over time, and what may have been acceptable at one point might later be deemed inappropriate or in violation of the rules. It's possible that the guidelines were updated after your profile picture was approved, leading to the ban.

It's also possible that another user reported your profile picture after it was initially approved, prompting a manual review and subsequent ban.

Best regards.

Is it possible to get a community guidelines ban for breaking the profile guidelines?