I can hear party chat but they cannot hear me. Xbox One S

It's weird, my mic works for party chat, it works for recording messages, works for talking to Cortana. It won't however work with game chat! No matter what game I'm in it shows that a mic is hooked up but the icon won't flash when i talk into it.

I've checked to make sure I'm not in a party and I'm not. Something is up Microsoft needs to fix this.

I have one but i cannot hear the other people in the chat or party. They can hear me though...

That is not the issue. He is on xbox and can talk normally until I join the party from my pc, at that point he can no longer hear people and people cannot hear him. I however can hear people and they can hear me. It is just one person that cannot use party
chat if i join on my pc.

So I tried plugging in a headphone/mic into the 3.5 mm port and it had the opposite effect: I could hear party chat but they couldn't hear me.

Then, for the hell of it, I removed that set and plugged the older headset in and all of a sudden party chat worked fine with the Dusk Shadow controller. I am now afraid of removing the headset so I have left it plugged in.

Seems strange that swapping headsets and ports worked. Its also strange that this fix worked with the other Dusk Shadow controller that was having the same issues.

Is there a batch of bad controllers out there that Amazon is selling?

Hey Bumzilla! The Dusk Shadow controller should work like any other controller. Here at the forums we don't have the ability to see inventory for a retailer. If you feel like the controller is not working as it should, we would suggest getting replaced by
the retailer. Thanks!