Do I need Xbox Live Gold on 2nd console?

Hiya Dread7,

I recommend to create a 2nd account (will not have the saves or game time the other account has) and set the first account (the account that has Xbox Live Gold) as the
home console to share the Xbox live gold. (You wouldn't have to buy a 2nd gold)

GameShare allows an account to share all of its console from one account to another.

1. The account that owns gold set it as the home on the 2nd console.

2. Keep the account that owns gold on the first account to play.

3. Create a second account and sign in on the 2nd console.

Hope this helps.

I'm not sure what you mean? If you plan on only getting and using 1 Xbox One console then you should be fine with paying for only 1 Xbox LIVE Gold Membership. Anyone that wants to use your console with their own gamertag will not need to pay for Xbox LIVE
Gold to get online. This is only for that 1 console. If you wish to purchase a 2nd Xbox One console then you'd need to get that console a gold membership as well so anyone can play on that console.

I hope that makes more sense, if not, I'll try to clarify some more for you.

Anything they purchased on their accounts should be accessible as long as they are signed into Live on any console. In order for them to access the gold/games purchased on your account, they would need to use your Home console. In order for them to share
the games they bought on their account with you or your other son, they would need to set a console as their Home and the 2nd son would have to use that console.

There is no longer a family gold pass. You don't necessary need Gold on every account. Your son's can use gold as long as their using your Home console, but if they need to use gold on the non-Home console, gold would need to be purchased on at least 1 of
their accounts and that account set the 2nd console as their Home.

Xbox Day One Console, a 2nd Wireless Controller, A game and an Xbox Live Gold 1 Year Membership

Have you done a license transfer to console 2? If not, was your profile signed into xbox LIVE on console 2? As I understand it, if you purchased the game on the 1st xbox then went to play it on the 2nd, you would need to have your profile on console 2 connected
to LIVE in order to access the content due to the licensing - unless you do a license transfer to the 2nd (in which case, your profile would need to be connected to LIVE on the 1st one to play it on that console).