Cant Play 2 players

It was a backwards compatible game? An Xbox One game?

Does the game allow guest accounts?

Can you please provide more information, so we can support you properly?

I had the same problem. Have the other person use the second controller and hit the xbox button or say xbox go home. Then move up to the top left of the screen and click the profile avatar. Then add guest and make sure the kinect identifies the second
player then click ok. Go back into the game and play.

Wow...im going to be playing a friend tmrrw......i would have never known to do that

Each controller needs to be linked to a profile to be used.(not just switched on)

I had exact the same problem playing my bro at 2k14 .

Like Trlggor said just go up top left corner of the home page and assign the free controller to a guest.

Its a weird way to do it, but once you know how then its not a problem.

Have been looking all over the net. Just cant find anything anywhere where Im only being able to play 2 players on one system and only 1 on the other. Doesnt matter which system which ever one starts the match can have 2 players and the other that joins
only 1 player.