Can You Not Play MLB The Show 24 Anymore?

No. It was removed from Game Pass and therefore, is not available on the cloud.

Yes, it will be available on the One. There is a standard edition for the One and both the MVP and Digital Deluxe Editions include the One version. https://www.xbox.com/en-US/games/mlb-the-show-24#purchaseoptions

Hello Dear User

Welcome to the Microsoft Community.

I understand that you are having trouble on can't play MLB the show 24 online, and I understand your confusion.

It sounds like you've been dealing with the "Challenge Failed" error in MLB The Show 24 for quite a while now. This can be quite frustrating, especially when it's been going on for months. There are several reasons this issue might occur, from network problems to issues with the game or server-side problems. Here are some steps to try and fix it:

Check Your Internet Connection

• Stable connection: Ensure you have a stable internet connection. Unstable Wi-Fi or intermittent network issues can cause online connectivity problems in games like MLB The Show.
  

• Wired connection: If you're using Wi-Fi, consider switching to a wired connection (Ethernet) to ensure a more stable and faster connection.
  

Clear Cache (Console-Specific)

Clearing the cache on your console might help fix any persistent issues with the game or the network:

• For PlayStation:
  

• Turn off your console.
  

• Hold the power button until you hear a second beep (about 7 seconds).
  

• Boot into Safe Mode and select Clear Cache.
  

• For Xbox:
  

• Press and hold the power button for 10 seconds to turn off the console completely.
  

• Unplug the console for 30 seconds, then plug it back in and restart.
  

Port Forwarding

MLB The Show might have issues if certain ports required for online play are blocked on your router.

• Check the necessary ports for MLB The Show 24 (usually listed on the game's support page or forums).
  

• Open the ports on your router by logging into your router settings and configuring port forwarding.
  

Check Your PlayStation or Xbox Account

• Account restrictions: Make sure there are no restrictions or bans on your account that could be affecting your ability to play online. This includes checking if your PlayStation Plus or Xbox Live subscription is active, as you need it for online play.
  

• Log in to the correct account: Double-check that you're logged into the correct PlayStation or Xbox account, as sometimes multiple accounts can cause issues.
  

Reinstall the Game

If the game files are corrupted, it could be causing the online connectivity error. Try uninstalling and reinstalling MLB The Show 24:

• Uninstall the game.
  

• Reinstall the game fresh from your console's store or disc (if applicable).
  

• This will reset any broken or corrupted files that might be causing the problem.
  

Update the Game and Console

Ensure that both your MLB The Show 24 and your console’s firmware are up to date:

• Game updates: Go to the game’s page on the store and check if there are any pending updates for the game.
  

• Console updates: Check for updates for your PlayStation or Xbox system software to make sure you're using the latest version.
  

Check for NAT Type Issues

Your NAT (Network Address Translation) type might be set to a restrictive setting, which can block some online features.

• Test your NAT type (find the setting in your console's network settings).
  

• Ideally, you want NAT Type 1 (Open) or Type 2 (Moderate). Type 3 (Strict) could cause issues, especially with online multiplayer games.
  

Try a Different Account or Device

If possible, try logging into a different account or even on a different console/device (if you have access). This can help you determine if the issue is specific to your account or console.

Contact Support

If none of the above solutions work, it may be time to contact MLB The Show 24’s support:

• Submit a request – The Show
  

• Provide as many details as possible about your issue to get the best help.
  
  Disclaimer: This is a non-Microsoft website. The page appears to be providing accurate and safe information. Watch out for ads on the site that may advertise products frequently classified as PUP (Potentially Unwanted Products). Thoroughly research any product advertised on the site before you decide to download and install it. 
  
  
  

Let me know if you need further help or if you find a specific solution.

Best Regards.

Lee-MSFT | Microsoft Community Support Specialist

That is bs. Buy anyways. I will finish my subscription then. Thanks.

The game has left game pass but still is playable if you purchased it