"But my video was from a Mature-rated title, why was it taken down?"

Discus and support "But my video was from a Mature-rated title, why was it taken down?" in XBoX Accessibility to solve the problem; From 6/24/22 - 6/27/22, I received a temporary suspension on my account for an "inappropriate feed item". It was a 45 second clip from a game called... Discussion in 'XBoX Accessibility' started by ABEZILLA, Jun 29, 2022.

  1. ABEZILLA
    ABEZILLA Guest

    "But my video was from a Mature-rated title, why was it taken down?"


    From 6/24/22 - 6/27/22, I received a temporary suspension on my account for an "inappropriate feed item". It was a 45 second clip from a game called The Quarry. In this clip, one of the survivors makes an annoying sound to distract the killers so that the other survivor has a chance to escape, afterwards one of the survivors gets shot in the head. I posted this clip to a club called "The Xbox Community" because I thought the annoying sound was funny. People liked it and shared it, but then someone reported it and it was taken down. I appealed the suspension but Xbox enforcement rejected it. During this suspension I was constantly being kicked out of multiplayer matches from three different online games which were Halo Infinite, Call of Duty: Warzone, and Evil Dead: The Game. This was NOT mentioned in the suspension notice at all. According to Xbox enforcement team's stance on this topic they state, "Xbox Live is designed for users of all ages and your clips and screenshots may be viewable by anyone!". Well then, isn't that the responsibility of parents/legal guardians to setup family settings to protect their little gamers? What is the point of being able to share M-rated content if people don't even bother setting up basic content restrictions for themselves or others if they get triggered over a video game clip/screenshot? To sum it up, I was wrongly suspended for an entire weekend, Xbox enforcement policy is flawed, and this opens the door for false reporting and unjustified account suspensions. After the suspension was lifted, I adjusted my account's privacy settings, deleted all my clips and screenshots that were uploaded to xbox live, and left all the clubs I joined on the platform. I cannot take any chances, I've invested so much into my xbox live account.

    So thanks Xbox enforcement team, you have forced me to isolate and remove myself from the Xbox community as a whole.

    :)
     
    ABEZILLA, Jun 29, 2022
    #1
  2. HAZMAT RADIO Win User

    Unclear message from Xbox

    For account suspensions or bans sign in at this site with your account at
    https://enforcement.xbox.com


    But my video was from a Mature-rated title, why was it taken down?
    Remember, Xbox Live is designed for users of all ages and your clips and screenshots may be viewable by anyone! You’re welcome to create content from a Mature-rated title, but Kinect content (including audio, video, and text) must be appropriate for an audience
    of all ages. Gameplay clips or screenshots that are likely to be perceived as provocative, including those featuring egregious violent or lewd content without adequate context, may also be considered inappropriate.

    https://enforcement.xbox.com/en-US/home/staysafe#topic8

    You should see how long the suspension is for at the enforcement site.

    If you can post clips now, maybe it was just a 24 hour suspension.
  3. HAZMAT RADIO Win User

    Videos Being Deleted

    The Xbox Enforcement Team does not use these forums. For information about your account suspensions or bans sign in at this site with your account at
    https://enforcement.xbox.com

    https://enforcement.xbox.com/en-US/home/staysafe#topic8

    Inappropriate Game DVR content includes, but is not limited to

    Use of profanity or other offensive terms or gestures

    Attempts to harass, abuse, or bully other individuals

    Nudity or other sexual content, including in-game sexual content

    Harm or violence against people or animals, or promotion of self-harm

    Cheating, or promoting the use of unauthorized game modifications

    Use of illegal drugs or controlled substances

    Other illegal activities

    Non-video game-focused content

    Why does the Xbox Live Policy & Enforcement Team care?

    Xbox Live is designed to be fun and safe for everyone; when people upload harmful or offensive content, it disrupts the Xbox Live experience for other gamers. We remove this offensive content to preserve the quality of our service, and to create a safe and
    welcoming environment for all.

    But my video was from a Mature-rated title, why was it taken down?

    Remember, Xbox Live is designed for users of all ages and your clips and screenshots may be viewable by anyone! You’re welcome to create content from a Mature-rated title, but Kinect content (including audio, video, and text) must be appropriate for an audience
    of all ages. Gameplay clips or screenshots that are likely to be perceived as provocative, including those featuring egregious violent or lewd content without adequate context, may also be considered inappropriate.
  4. ANIM4L CHIN Win User

    Profanity filter

    It's rated M= MATURE

    Titles rated M (Mature) have content that may be suitable for persons ages 17 and older. Titles in this category may contain intense violence, blood and gore, sexual content and/or strong language.
  5. WarpedSeneschal Win User

    Growing older with video games.

    Not to mention the games have matured with the gamers and offer great adult entertainment, thus the "mature" ratings on many titles.
  6. isturbo1984 Win User

    GameStop Kids

    [quote user="US Revenge"]

    [quote user="BizarroMantis"]

    I actually think it's a great idea. Ever go into a gamestop with a kid? They are drawn to all of the mature games. It can be very frustrating.

    [/quote]

    you wonder why?

    it's because all the good games are rated mature, and ratings are w.e ESRB is worse then the MPAA with ratings

    " it has blood, rated M" is pretty common.

    [/quote]I'll add my two cents to serve as a bump over the football adds, but...

    rated M games dont automatically mean they are better games. kids have been doing that for years. its only been recently that the AAA titles have been usually rated M... it used to be well-diversed in the ratings that hosted the AAA titles, but i agree that
    they all seem to be M today.
Thema:

"But my video was from a Mature-rated title, why was it taken down?"

Loading...
  1. "But my video was from a Mature-rated title, why was it taken down?" - Similar Threads - video was Mature

  2. Xbox game bar recording stops randomly, how to find back the video?

    in XBoX on Consoles
    Xbox game bar recording stops randomly, how to find back the video?: I was screen recording a game on my Windows 11 PC using Xbox Game Bar when the recording suddenly stopped for no reason. I checked my Captures folder, but the video wasn’t there—1 hour and 52...
  3. Video recording and screenshotting randomly stops working on Xbox Series S

    in XBoX Games and Apps
    Video recording and screenshotting randomly stops working on Xbox Series S: I'm not sure when this started happening but I noticed this around week ago. When this happens "Record what happened" do nothing, "Capture screenshot" do nothing, "Start recording" shows...
  4. Can someone show me a video on how I can disable touch hud on Xbox cloud gaming

    in XBoX Games and Apps
    Can someone show me a video on how I can disable touch hud on Xbox cloud gaming: Can someone show me a video on how I can disable touch hud on Xbox cloud gaming 4162b01d-3fd3-496b-b9bf-66653dc72925
  5. xbox game bar video capture - cannot record

    in XBoX Games and Apps
    xbox game bar video capture - cannot record: Hi my xbox game bar- - capture - cannot record. have updated windows, did the reset and repair steps. nothing works cc82ba75-7c1b-40b1-aef4-dc595ca04693
  6. Can't listen to Spotify on my Xbox: I see the video but no sound

    in XBoX Games and Apps
    Can't listen to Spotify on my Xbox: I see the video but no sound: The Spotify on my Xbox had some random ****'s gay music on it. Her name was "mama's music' or somthing dumb like that. Either way, haven't been able to listen to music on my Spotify via my Xbox...
  7. On alpha skip ahead been getting issues with video memory

    in XboX Insiders
    On alpha skip ahead been getting issues with video memory: Been playing borderlands 3 been having a blast bust keep getting this constant error i have over 50gb of ssd space, obviously not that I know but still could of been related, and I keep getting...
  8. Allow us to record mic and party audio with friends & stream to YouTube & video editor

    in XboX Insiders
    Allow us to record mic and party audio with friends & stream to YouTube & video editor: I think this should be a feature in an update a content creator to allow us Xbox users that make videos record our mic and chat party Some of us can't afford capture cards Don't have powerful...
  9. Green screen for video but no audio issues

    in XboX Insiders
    Green screen for video but no audio issues: So in the last couple of days I have only been getting a green screen for video I play on edge and some apps. I have no issues with audio and I generally figure the only solution is a hard reset...
  10. Videos start Dimming on YouTube App

    in XboX Insiders
    Videos start Dimming on YouTube App: So for some reason, my screen is dimming while in YouTube. I checked if this happened in other apps and games and no it just happened in YouTube. It isn't the Idle dimming that the Xbox usually...