2 xbox one's on one network

Here's the thing. We have two xbox one consoles in our house. After weeks of trying I have managed to get one xbox on an open NAT and the other stays on strict, unless the other signs in first, which results in mine staying on an open NAT setting and the
other on moderate. These kind of problems never occurred with the 360's. Here's what I've tried so far:

1. I made one xbox DMZ and port forwarded for the other. The results are as above.

2. Port triggering resulted in one strict and one moderate.

3. enable UPnP resulted in moderate and strict.

4. Giving one xbox his set up on the modem and leaving the other on the router. Results are as above.

I just can't find a guide that'll help me get both xbox one's on an open NAT setting. I tried the troubleshooting on the xbox forums, but pardon my language, but the troubleshooting on here is a POS.

My router is a cisco linksys E4200, with the latest firmware. My modem is a UBEE, supplied by my ISP.

I'm open to any and all suggestions, even advice on routers that can get these two xbox one's on open NAT with just UPnP. Getting tired of not being able to play with my husband online, talk in party-chat etc etc, because of something as stupid as this. Please
help me.

:)

 

Xbox One Energy-Inefficient?

By 2 others I mean, 2 more Xbox One's. I have 3 active Xbox One's set to Instant On.

 

Network Attached Stoarge

DLNA != share support

Don't expect Xbox One to ever support accessing network shares. If one's NAS has a DLNA server, that may see support. If one's NAS is just providing shares, it is unlikely that it will ever work with Xbox One.

 

Greetings Jenneke!

You can't manually add explicit rules (Port Forwarding, Port Triggering, DMZ) to be mapped on your router, as long as you connect more than one Xbox One to the same router/NAT Internet connection. This can only be accomplished by a well-behaved implemantation
of UPnP-IGD, or automatic port forwarding.

[quote user="Jenneke88"]My modem is a UBEE, supplied by my ISP[/quote]Appreciate if you can provide the make and model for this device.

[quote user="Jenneke88"]My router is a cisco linksys E4200[/quote]If you haven't already, I would suggest that you start by visit Linksys website, just to make sure your router (model- & hardware revision number) is up-to-date with the latest
version of firmware.

I would also suggest that you turn off Block/Filter Anonymous Internet Requests, which is a feature to be found in the firewall settings of your router's web-utility interface. A features that may block, or filter multiplex inbound Connections,
are not healthy for NAT traversal.

Could you also try change the
power mode, on both of your console's (if this is set to Instant-On), to energy-saving power mode.

Bear in mind! The Linksys E4200 has been
official confirmed it will not consistently work without NAT issues, regarding multiple console support.

Post back and let us know how that goes.

 

I contacted both my isp and linksys. Neither could help me. In the end, I purchased a new router and now my nat is moderate. I am satisfied. Thank you for the help taidara.

 

Great stuff!

Happy gaming and play safe!