2 xbox in same house and we can't play together in one lobby.

We are having the same issue. We have 2 xbox ones in the same house. Open Nat with Dlink router and repeater. Can't play co-op games with each other and can't party chat with each other. Nothing wrong with my router because we play another game with party
chat on 2 different xbox 360s within the same house on the same network and everything works fine. These xbox ones are becoming really bad.

My partner and I are experiencing the same issue. Two XBox Ones on one router. Cannot join each other in a lobby due to a Lost Connection error. Have had this issue since the game launched, don't have any problems joining other game lobbies together (Dead
Rising 3, Marvel Super Heroes, etc) HUGE DISAPPOINTMENT with this game. I can't believe it's a multiplayer-only game and we can't play together.

Thanks for the quick reply.

So his Gold account can't cover his Home Xbox console & mine at the same time even though they are in the same house?

For us to play online games together on separate consoles we would need 2 Gold subscriptions?

Right there with you buddy. They can't honestly expect me to buy multiple Gold memberships for one household either. Especially, when they did away with the Family Gold plan in exchange for the Gold sharing. I mean, I already have
$2000 worth of xboxes in my house. (still have both of my old 360s and my original xboxes along with 2 Xb ones) I have 2 kids and we all like to play games together, I would LOVE to buy an X and have all 3 of us playing together at the same time. But there's
NO WAY I will be buying another gold subscription and 2 copies of EVERY game we already have and will buy, not to mention the DLC's.. We all live under the same roof for heavens sake.

Since the last update, the kid and I are no longer able to play games together unless we both have copies. Not only that but I can't play any of his digital games and vice versa. We live in the same house.