2 x box consoles

Yes he would. Anything he purchased on his account would be tied to his account and he can redownload them on any console he uses. As long as he's playing online, the saves are stored on the cloud and he can use them on both consoles.

You can only share the gold on 1 console at a time. Son A can sign into gold and use it on any console he wants. In order for Son B to share the gold, he would only be able to use it on the console Son A has set as his Home.

To be clear I have 2 sons and they both want to use the X box Gold subscription for son A

I play the game on two different X Box One consoles and a PS4 with no problems. Have 6 other friends (1P.C., 2 PS4, and 3 X Box One.) that play with no problems. Comes to a 100% satisfaction rate! Are you sure you're not sticking the disc into the toaster?
;-)

Peace, J.R.

I semi agree with the op. X Box One is boring, had more fun on X Box 360. Got so boring that I didn't renew my gold membership last month. My dad has an X Box One X, but he doesn't go on it a lot. My mum watches Netflix with it. I still have my X Box 360
console tucked in my wardrobe. Well now there's cross platform multiplayer, but over half the people we're on a different platform, not an X Box One console, the long multiplayer loading screens, people with no mics, and not enough people round my age on the
console, which sucks. My best friend has a Windows 10 laptop which has the X Box Companion App thingy. Welp I won't have to fight over the X Box One console. X Box is still kwl though ^-^.