2 microsoft or gamertag in one email

Make sure that email#2 is not logged in on any devices as a Microsoft Account except on your Xbox console as it may automatically generate a gamertag. After moving the gamertag under email#2, you can contact Xbox Support to check if there is no more gamertag
under email#2 so you can proceed moving gamertag under email#1 to email#2.

It is not possible to have 2 gamertags associated to the same account. It is also not possible to transfer gamertags from one account to another. So the only possible explanation is that you have 2 different accounts with different email addresses used
to log in. To try to find the email address used to log in to the other account please use the Forgot email address for
Microsoft account solution.

gamertag 1 is the email you want

gamertag 2 is the gamertag you account you want to move it to

well typically you don't move a gamertag 1 to more then one account

first you free an account with the email you want with the one you created

that frees it up

then you use the email you want on the gamertag 2

so unless you are swaping two emails between two accounts you do have to wait the 30days on one of them

I would call support and tell them all the emails and or gamertags that are coming up so they can work with you to figure out whats going on. Could be a possible typo in the email that could look like 2 gamertags with one 1 email when really its either a
different email or a typo'd email. Or on the even rarer occasion it could be a broke Microsoft account.

1 Microsoft Account Email can not have 2 Gamertag's associated to it and yes, make sure you have no Microsoft Currency (MSFT Points, Xbox Cash, etc.) when you change your emails.

Follow these instructions:

support.xbox.com/.../switch-gamertag-to-different-microsoft-account

Keep in mind that your new Microsoft Account Email that you want to use on your current Gamertag, MUST have its Security Proofs and Billing Information associated to it at account.live.com and have been ACTIVE for at least 30 days, without a Gamertag already
associated to it, prior to changing the Microsoft Account email associated to your Gamertag. If you did already make a Gamertag to it, then you have to create a new Microsoft Account Email, add/verify proofs, 30 days to use that new one.

Make sense? Let me know if that helped!