Need help finding e-mail connected to Xbox live gamertag

It's not possible to have the same e-mail associated with 2 Xbox LIVE accounts. If your gamertag was given a FNC (forced name change) and you actually changed the gamertag yourself then that gamertag is still active as shown
here.

You are using the wrong e-mail to login to the account, you will need to contact Xbox Support to find out the e-mail associated with the gamertag that you had previously.

You need a third 'dummy' E-mail for this. A gamertag will always need an E-mail ascosiated with it. So its like a game of musical chairs. With the third E-mail you will, for e.g. bring it to this gamertag and swap it for its WLID then that E-mail will be
free to be swapped with your secondary account. The E-mail on your secondary will be free to be swapped for the WLID that you put on the gamertag and the Third 'Dummy' E-mail can be forgotten about. Hope that helps.

Hello, your "profile" is your "gamertag" if it was an online profile. If you had a different gamertag previously, from the looks of your post I'm guessing it was "Roguemant". You will need to download your profile using the e-mail and password associated
with that account. If you can't remember what that e-mail address is you will need to contact phone support and speak with them about this.

Each gamertag can only have one e-mail attached to it, so you would need to use the e-mail associated with the gamertag "Roguemant" to be able to download that "profile" to your XBOX 360 console. If you have access to your previous XBOX still and that that
account is still accessible on that console you will be able to view what e-mail is on that gamertag by going to the XBOX 360 Dashboard > Settings > Account > Manage > Windows Live ID. The e-mail should be listed there, login with that e-mail.

Does your XBOX 360 console sign into the correct gamertag "Maddison Monroe"? If so please check which Windows Live ID is on that account and what Windows Live ID you are using to sign into this XBOX.com account. Please make sure to physically check and not
just say it is as other's have said the same thing and when they go to physically check on their XBOX 360 the e-mail addresses are different.

To check the e-mail address that is on your XBOX 360's gamertag please do the following:

My XBOX > Select your Gamertag and press A > Go to the Account Management Tab > It will list Windows Live ID

Please confirm that this Windows Live ID is showing up under:

http://www.xbox.com > Hover over My XBOX > Select Accounts > From there select Contact Preferences on the right and check the e-mail address.

It's most likely not the same, if it's not then please recover RevoltingDock02 using the e-mail address you are using to login to XBOX.com with onto your XBOX 360 and change the e-mail on the gamertag to something else so it's free to use for your primary gamertag
"Maddison Monroe". If you need help with finding out how to change the e-mail on your gamertag follow the directions on this website:

support.xbox.com/.../manage-live-id.aspx

When it says "Windows Live ID is associated with a different gamertag" that means that the e-mail is already tied to this gamertag. You won't be able to use this same e-mail for that account. You would need to use a totally different e-mail that's not tied
to any account.