How do I combine two microsoft accounts under different emails into one account with the...

Nothing can be transferred between accounts and it's not possible to merge accounts.

I have two accounts with identical email addresses and passwords, one of which I use for my Xbox and the other of which I created accidentally, but when I attempt to log into my primary account, it logs into the accidental account, and I'm not sure what to do.

There has to be some sort of slight difference in the emails. Even if its just a very minor difference.

Its not possible to have two different Microsoft/Xbox accounts under the same exact email address.

How else would it know what account to log you into if it allowed you to have two accounts under the same email? It just wouldn't.

Hey there!

How are you saying that you have two profiles under one email? This would not be possible as you are only able to register one Xbox profile per Microsoft account. Please explain how you use two different accounts under one email, is there two separate gamertags
for you and one for them?

Unfortunately you are unable to move the Gamertag from one Microsoft account to another either. The only way to actually update the email address would be to

Update the Primary Alias on the account as CIDkidzPILLZ has mentioned above.

I hope this helps.

If I'm understanding the question, you have original account A on email A, and on the Xbox, you have account B on email B. you want to combine the two accounts together and use them on the Xbox.

-

If that is the case, unfortunately you can't combine/merge the two accounts together.

-

If you want to use account A on email B (or account B on email A), you will need a third email address. The steps to do switch can be found here:

support.xbox.com/.../switch-gamertag-to-different-microsoft-account

-

Please let us know if this helps, or if I totally misunderstood what you were asking.

How do I create a new Microsoft account with the same email address as the Microsoft account I am using right now, when I go to create a new account it says I can't use the email because it's already used for this account?

What the person above said is flat out incorrect as far as I am aware.

Unless something has changed very recently youve never been able to have two different Microsoft accounts under the same primary email address. Its always been one unique email per account.